Which one, which one?

So im trying to decide where im going for high school and i have to descide so because if i go to the one school then i need to enroll so. but i don't know where i should go. so i want you opion on which school sounds better. and hopefully that will help me. so here are the factors:

School #1 GOOD Factors
LOTS of students
Public school(no tuition).
completely new to me
bestest friend is here
A really good friend here
a couple ok friends here
not following brother being different from him
volleyball.
drama
lots of options for classes(french, photography)
cuter guys(lolz)
dances with friends(could be fun)
meet completly new people

Bad factors
because of being big less chance of getting on volleyball team
because of being big less chance of being in a drama production
dances might not fun with who im with

School #2 GOOD Factors
Small. get more attention
better chance of getting on volleyball team
better chance of being in drama production
really good friend going here
couple of ok friends(don't really like them but still hangs out with)
dances will be fun
know mostly everyone

Bad Factors
Private school(pay expensive tuition (can't really afford))
basically the same as where im at now
few options for classes(core classes, no option of language must be spanish(ick))
very small(couple hundred students)
not very many new people
NOT cute guys
same as my brother, in his shadow

So which option sounds better to you? PLEASE COMMENT!!!!

*AWAITING YOU ANSWERS*

~RUBY